Thursday, March 3, 2016

Rich, Entitled, and Narcissistic


Narcissists are self-centered people who take the view that they are far more important than the people around them.  They promote themselves to the exclusion of others and take other people’s successes as competition to their own.  They also tend to suck the life out of groups, because they steal the limelight and push their own agenda at the expense of others.

Because of these negative influences of narcissism on relationships and in the workplace, it is valuable to understand where this collection of traits comes from.  An interesting paper in the January, 2014 issue of Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin by Paul Piff explores the relationship between narcissism and wealth. 

He argues that great wealth and higher levels of social class can lead people to have a greater sense of entitlement and that sense can lead to narcissism. 

In one study, adults ranging in age from 18-72 filled out a series of surveys including two of importance for this project.  One showed participants a ladder with ten rungs on it that represent people of increasing levels of income, education, and prestige and asked them to select the run they belong to.  This is a measure of perceived socioeconomic status (SES).  The second measure was a questionnaire measuring people’s sense of entitlement with items like “I honestly feel that I am more deserving than others.”  This study found a small positive correlation between the measure of SES and the measure of sense of entitlement. 

A second study used college students.  As a measure of SES, students reported their parents’ income.  As a measure of entitlement, the author used a scale that asked people to rate the relative importance of themselves compared to others.  This measure had a circle representing other people and circles of different sizes that could represent the self.  They had to select a size of a circle representing the self that corresponded to their feelings about their own importance compared to other people.  Previous studies suggest that this measure relates to people’s sense of entitlement.  Finally, participants filled out an inventory that assesses narcissism. 
In this study, there was a small correlation between SES (as measured by parental income) and narcissism.  There was also a small correlation between SES and the measure of entitlement.   

Statistical tests suggested that the sense of entitlement explained the differences in narcissism between low- and high-SES participants. 

A third study gathered measures of SES from college students in the lab.  Other measures were collected including a measure of how much participants care about their appearance.  Toward the end of the study, participants were asked if they would allow the experimenter to take their picture for a future study on face recognition.  Participants were given the opportunity to look in the mirror to fix their appearance before the picture.  The experimenter left the room to get a camera, and another RA measured whether the participant looked in the mirror.  Overall, women tended to look in the mirror more often than men.  That reflects a general difference between men and women in how much they care about their appearance.  Beyond that, high-SES individuals looked in the mirror more often than low-SES individuals.  This difference was not explained by differences in how much these individuals care about their appearance.

Finally, one study did an experimental manipulation to break the relationship between SES and narcissism.  Participants drawn from a sample on Amazon’s Mechanical Turk filled out a measure of SES.  Then, participants either listed three benefits of treating others as equals (which primes the concept of equality) or listed three activities they do in a normal day (a control condition).  Finally, participants filled out a narcissism scale. 

For the participants in the control condition, there was a small positive relationship between SES and narcissism.  That relationship disappeared for the group that wrote about equality.

Putting this together, then, there is a weak relationship between SES and narcissism.  When people grow up and live in a privileged environment, it can increase their tendency to feel entitled. That sense of entitlement leads to greater narcissism.

As interesting as these results are, it is important to recognize that the effects overall are small.  There are plenty of people high in socioeconomic status who have neither a sense of entitlement nor a tendency toward narcissism.  Similarly, there are many people from a low-SES background who do have a sense of entitlement and narcissistic traits.  But, it is valuable to know that there are elements of a person’s social situation that can make them more susceptible to being a narcissist. 

Thursday, February 25, 2016

Stopping Unwanted Behaviors


By the end of January every year, many people who made New Year’s resolutions discover that it is hard to keep them.  By mid-February, most people who resolved to change their behavior will find that they have failed and are back to their old habits.

One difficulty with changing behavior is that you have to stop doing an undesired behavior, and ultimately replace it with one or more desired behaviors.  As I discuss in Smart Change, your actions are governed by two brain networks that can be called the Go System and the Stop System.  The Go System engages goals and promotes action.  The Stop System inhibits behaviors that the Go System has begun to execute.  Your ability to stop a behavior successfully, then, depends on two factors: how strongly the Go System is engaged and how effectively the Stop System can inhibit an action.

Psychologists have developed a number of laboratory tasks that can be used to study the Go and Stop systems in action.  One interesting task was used in a paper in the December, 2013 issue of Psychological Science by Julie Bugg and Michael Scullin.  This task is called the Prospective Memory task.  Participants are told that they will see a number of strings of letters (like DUCK or DCUK) and they will have to respond whether the letters form a word by pressing buttons on a computer keyboard.  This task is called a Lexical Decision task.  However, participants are also told that there are two special target words (say, CORN and DANCER).  If they see one of the target words, they should press a third button to indicate they saw the target.  

After doing that task for 80 trials, participants are then told that they will continue to do a lexical decision task, but the target task is now over, so they should only respond whether the letters they see form a word.  Even if one of the target words from the first part of the study appears again, they should not press the special key.  They key measure in this study is whether participants mistakenly press the special button when they see one of the words that had been a target in the first part of the study.

Previous research with this task suggests that the more times people see the target words in the first part of the task, the more likely that they will be to mistakenly continue to press the button in the second part of the task.  The idea is that when you see the words many times in the first part of the task, it activates the Go System more strongly, and that makes it harder for the Stop System to overcome the temptation to press the key in the second part of the task.

In this latest paper, though, the researchers explored an interesting case.  Some participants saw target words 4 times in the first part of the study.  Other participants never saw target words in the first part of the study.  In the second part of the study, all participants saw words that had been targets 10 times over 260 trials.  Surprisingly, 56% of the participants who never saw targets in the first part of the study mistakenly pressed the target button at least once, but none of the participants who saw the target words 4 times in the first part of the study mistakenly pressed the target button.

What is going on here? 

The first part of the study creates the goal to respond to the target words.  When people see those target words 4 times in the first part of the study the Go System recognizes that the goal has been achieved, and so its activation is dampened in the second part of the study.  When people never see the target words in the first part of the study, the Go System remains active in the second part of the study, which makes it harder for the Stop System to completely overcome the desire to act.  

As a demonstration of this point, another study in this paper repeated this study.  This time, participants were once again focused on two target words in the first part of the study.  This time, 4 targets appeared in the first part of the study, but participants saw only one of the two target words (so half of the participants saw only CORN and the other half saw only DANCER).  In the second part of the study, participants were much more likely to mistakenly press the special button when they saw the target that had not appeared in the first part of the study than when they saw the target that had appeared.

Why does this matter?

When you try to change your behavior, you probably focus most on stopping the undesired behaviors.  It may be even more important to find ways to dampen the activity of the Go System to make the undesired behaviors easier to overcome.  One way to do that can be to perform the undesired behavior a little in order to make the Go System believe that it has achieved its goal rather than avoiding the undesired behavior altogether.

Obviously, there is a gap between these simple laboratory studies and the real world.  So, there needs to be more research that helps to translate these intriguing findings into specific recommendations. 

Monday, February 15, 2016

Testosterone, Trust, and Social Status


Over the past several years, much has been made of the psychological influences of the hormone Oxytocin on behavior.  It has been called the love hormone and the trust hormone.  And there are some findings out there to support that increases in oxytocin levels can increase positive thoughts toward a partner and trust in some cases.  

In that same time period, there has been much less discussion of the influence of testosterone on social relationships.  This topic is explored in a paper by Maarten Boksem, Pranjal Mehta, Bram Van den Bergh, Veerle van Son, Stefan Trautann, Karin Roelofs, Ale Smidts, and Alan Sanfey in the November, 2013 issue of Psychological Science. 

In this paper, participants were women who were either given a dose of testosterone or a placebo.  Women were used, because men’s level of testosterone fluctuates significantly throughout the day.  The testing was done about 4 hours after the administration of the testosterone, because previous studies suggest that the strongest influence of testosterone on behavior occurs about 4 hours after the testosterone is released into the bloodstream.

Participants played two economic games.  In the first, they were given 20 Euros, and were told that they were playing with a partner.  They could give as much of that 20€ to the other participant.  The experimenter would then triple the donation, and the partner could return as much of that amount as they chose to the original donor.  For example, if the participant gave 10€ to the partner, the partner would get 30€, which they could split ay way they like with the participant.  This game is a measure of trust, because the participant has to trust that they will get back from the other player at least as much as they gave up. 

After playing one round of this trust game participants were then told that they were playing the other side of the game.  Now, they were given 60€, with the explanation that the other player had given their full 20€, and were asked how much they wanted to return to the other player.  This game is a measure of how much people are willing to reciprocate in social situations.

The trust game results suggest that testosterone decreases trust.  Participants gave about 54% of their money to their partner when they received the placebo, but gave only about 38% of their money when they received testosterone. 

The reciprocation game suggests that testosterone increases reciprocation.  Participants returned only about 43% of the money when given the placebo, but returned about 53% of the money when given testosterone.

Other measures taken during this study suggest that testosterone did not make participants more tolerant of risky options or more tolerant of ambiguous situations.

What does all of this mean?

The finding that testosterone decreases trust is consistent with a lot of work that suggests that testosterone makes people vigilant for violations that may disrupt a person’s social standing.

The reciprocation effects are interesting, though.  When a person reciprocates in a game like this, they are sending a signal that they can be relied on in social situations.  When people can be relied upon, that generally increases their social standing.  So, testosterone may be helping people to act in a way that improves their social position.

Of course, the doses of testosterone used in this study are much higher than what women will naturally experience.  Further research needs to explore whether similar effects can be obtained with testosterone levels that are similar to those that occur naturally.

Monday, February 8, 2016

The Attractiveness of Average and Familiar Faces


Over the years, many studies have examined what people find attractive in faces.  One important factor is symmetry.  If you draw a line down the middle of someone’s face, the more similar the right and left sides of the face, the more attractive it is seen to be.  Evolutionary psychologists have argued that we like symmetry in faces, because it is a sign of health.  

Symmetry is not the only factor that affects attractiveness, of course.  For example, Marilyn Monroe had a prominent mole on only one side of her face.  This mole may have helped to draw people’s attention to her face, which then increased her perceived beauty.

One demonstration that symmetry is important to judgments of facial attractiveness comes from morphing studies.  In these experiments, people rate the attractiveness of a series of faces along with one face that is the morphed average of the set of faces.  This morphed average is generally seen as more attractive than the mean rating of all of the faces from which it was generated.  A big reason for this advantage for the average face is that it is much more symmetric than the individual faces from which it was generated.  The morphing process eliminates the asymmetries in the individual faces.  

An interesting paper by Jamin Halberstadt, Diane Pecher, Rene Zeelenberg, Laurent Ip Wai, and Piotr Winkielman in the November, 2013 issue of Psychological Science demonstrates that the familiarity of a face may play an even bigger role in the attractiveness of the faces than symmetry.  

The authors started with 28 pictures of celebrities from the Netherlands and 28 pictures of celebrities from New Zealand.  They created morphs of pairs of faces to create 14 morphs.  Then, participants from the Netherlands and New Zealand rated the attractiveness of the morphs as well as the attractiveness of the individual faces.  All of the morphs were rated first.   
Participants were also asked whether they recognized the morphs and the individual faces. 

When participants rated faces of celebrities from another country, the typical averaging effect was observed.  The New Zealand participants found the morphs of two Dutch celebrities to be more attractive than the individual photos.  The Dutch participants found the morphs of two celebrities from New Zealand to be more attractive than the individual photos.

When people judged celebrities from their own country, though, familiarity took over.  On average, the ratings of the individual faces of celebrities from that culture were seen as more attractive than the morphs.  The more strongly that a person recognized the celebrity, the more strongly they preferred the individual faces to the morphs.

This study is a nice demonstration of the influence of familiarity on judgments.  We are wired to prefer familiar things to unfamiliar ones. For example, the mere exposure effect demonstrates that seeing something even once makes it more desirable than something that has never been seen before.  So, even though there may be general factors that can make something attractive or desirable, there is no substitute for making it familiar.

Monday, January 25, 2016

Can You Tell When Someone Is Lying?


I love movies about con artists.  David Mamet’s early film House of Games is a great example.  Throughout the film, it is hard to tell who is lying and who is telling the truth.   The success of movies like this is that it is often difficult to be certain that someone is lying to you.  
 
Over the years, many studies have demonstrated that people are not that good at determining when someone is lying to them.  Part of the problem is that there are no obvious cues that separate lying from truth telling.  Another part of the problem is that we often use the wrong cues.   So, people often focus on whether someone is moving their body in a nervous way or averting their gaze when speaking, but those characteristics are not good cues to whether someone is lying.

That does not mean that it is impossible to judge whether someone is lying.  A paper in the November, 2013 issue of the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology by Marc-Andre Reinhard, Rainer Greifeneder, and Martin Scharmach explored how different types of thought affect accuracy at lie detection.

Often, we solve problems and make judgments with conscious thought.  If I ask you whether a particular person is lying to you, you might spend some time thinking about your interaction and then make a judgment.  

Sometimes, though, you engage in unconscious thought.  You know you have a problem to solve or a judgment to make, but you walk away from the problem and work on other things.  Then, you come back to the problem.  In those cases, you find that you are now thinking about the problem in a different way.  

The researchers suggested that people might be more accurate at detecting liars after unconscious thought than after conscious thought.  The idea is that unconscious thought may be able to take more characteristics of an interaction into consideration than conscious thought does.  In addition, unconscious thought may capture aspects of an interaction that would be hard to isolate when thinking consciously.  

In one study, participants watched videos of people who either told truthful stories about an event that happened to them, or they lied.  One group made a judgment after each video about whether the person was telling the truth.  A second group watched the entire set of videos and then was asked to think about each video consciously for several minutes and then to judge whether that person was telling the truth.  A third group watched the entire set of videos and then was told they would be judging whether the individuals told the truth.  After that, they engage in a difficult distracting task for several minutes so that they could not consciously think about their judgments.  Then, they judged whether the speakers were telling the truth. 

The participants who made immediate judgments and those who had a chance to deliberate consciously had difficulty determining who was telling the truth and who was lying.  The participants who engaged in unconscious thought were much better at this task and were able to identify the truth tellers and liars about 65% of the time.  That is not perfect, of course, but it is better than random guessing.

In these studies, how can you tell whether the improvement comes from actual unconscious thought or whether it is just a result of being distracted for a while after hearing the people? 

For unconscious thought, the individual needs to be pursuing a goal (like determining whether the person is lying).  In one study, participants observed people who were either telling the truth or lying.  Some were told to deliberate consciously about whether the person was telling the truth.  Some were told that they were going to judge whether the people were telling the truth and then were given a distractor task until it was time to make the judgments.  A third group did the distractor task without being told anything about determining whether people were telling the truth.  Then, they made the judgments.  Only the group that was told they were going to make judgments and then were distracted were reasonably good at separating the liars from the truth-tellers.   So, it appears that unconscious thought rather than mere distraction is affecting people’s judgments.

In one final study, participants were exposed to a large number of videos of people telling the truth or lying.  These videos were carefully coded for a variety of cues like the number of details included in the stories, how much eye contact people made, and the amount of tension in the voice.  Analyses of these cues were done against whether the person was actually telling the truth.  Many of the cues (like eye gaze) were not at all correlated with whether the person was telling the truth.  Some (like facial pleasantness) were reliably associated with telling the truth.  Others (like vocal tension) were reliably associated with lying.

In this study, some participants judged whether the speakers were telling the truth immediately.  Some engaged in conscious deliberation.  Others engaged in an unconscious thought condition.  As before, those in the unconscious thought condition did a better job of separating the truth-tellers from the liars.  Statistical analyses were used to determine what cues the groups used to make their judgments.  Participants in the control and conscious thought conditions tended to pay attention to cues that are easy to detect like eye gaze that are not actually correlated with whether people were telling the truth.  Participants in the unconscious thought condition were much more likely to use cues like vocal tension and the length of pauses in speech that are actually associated with lying.

Putting this all together, it is clear that it is very hard to determine whether someone is lying to you.  If you are concerned about trying to make a judgment about lying, though, you should give yourself a little time away from the interaction before coming back to make the judgment.  That will improve your odds of figuring out whether you were being lied to.

Of course, if you are really worried you are being lied to, perhaps you need to spend time with a different group of people.

Monday, January 18, 2016

The Danger of Indifference


One of the themes in this blog over the years is goal contagion, which is the idea that we often adopt the goals of the people around us.  See someone helping others, and you suddenly want to be helpful.  See someone being aggressive, and it makes you more likely to engage aggressively with others.

What about apathy?

If you see people being indifferent about a task, is that contagious as well?

That question was explored in a paper in the August, 2014 issue of the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology by Pontus Leander, James Shah, and Stacey Sanders.  

They suggested that when people are wavering in their commitment to a goal, then being exposed to apathy decreases people’s motivation to pursue a task.

In one study, participants performed twelve GRE analogy problems.   Prior to solving these problems, participants did a task in which they responded to words presented in the center of the screen.  Prior to seeing the words, pictures were flashed quickly on the screen.  These pictures either showed students looking bored or students looking engaged.  A control group saw no pictures.  The pictures were flashed quickly enough that they could be perceived subliminally.  After solving the GRE problems, participants were asked for their undergraduate grade-point average, which is a broad measure of their commitment to academic work.

Participants with a high GPA were relatively unaffected by the prime.  Those with a low GPA solved fewer analogy problems when they were primed by apathetic students than when they were primed by energetic students or received no priming at all.  

This result suggests that exposure to apathy can decrease the motivation for people who are already unsure of their commitment to a goal.  Another study used primes for apathy and primes for anger.  Only primes for apathy led people to perform more poorly on a later test.  This finding suggests that apathy is not just creating negative emotion that influences performance.

Another study used a more sensitive measure of commitment to academic achievement.  Once again, participants were exposed to images of people being either apathetic or not.  For half the participants, the images showed academic situations, and for half the participants, the images were of nonacademic situations.  All participants then solved anagrams, which they were told were a measure of verbal fluency.  For example, they might see the letter ECTAR and would have to form the word CRATE.  

An interesting pattern of results was obtained.  The prime that was not in an academic context had very little influence on people’s behavior.  

The pictures in an academic context had an interesting influence on people’s behavior.  Participants who were not strongly committed to academic achievement spent less time on the anagrams and solved fewer anagrams when they saw pictures priming apathy than when they saw pictures unrelated to apathy.  Participants who were strongly committed to academic achievement actually spent more time on the anagrams and solved more of them when they saw pictures related to apathy than when they saw pictures unrelated to apathy.

This pattern suggests two conclusions.  First, the influence of apathy is situation specific.  Second, the influence of seeing apathy depends on a person’s commitment to the goal.  People who are not committed to the goal interpret apathy as a signal that they should also give up.  People who are strongly committed to the goal actually get even more committed by seeing apathy.

The researchers ran several other studies to rule out other interpretations of the study.  For example, one study demonstrated that just thinking about the goal does not lead to these effects.  The influence of apathy requires that people have either a low or high commitment to the goal.

What does all of this mean?

We interpret the actions of the people around us.  When we see people acting indifferently to a task, we know that they are expressing a lack of interest in that task.  That lack of interest is then related to people’s existing commitment to a goal.  When people are wavering in their commitment to a goal, then seeing others who are apathetic nudges them in the direction of giving up.  When people are highly committed to the goal, then seeing others who are apathetic actually increases their commitment to the goal.

Wednesday, January 6, 2016

What Causes People to Donate After Disasters?


Technology has made it easy for people to give donations following natural disasters.  When reports of floods, typhoons, hurricanes, and earthquakes makes news, there are websites available for people to give money.  People can even use their phones to donate money by text message.  

What factors lead people to give money to a particular disaster?

In the news reports following a disaster, there are usually estimates of the number of people who were killed as well as the number of individuals who were affected.  The affected individuals have often lost their homes and are in urgent need of food, shelter, sanitation, and medical care.  Much of the money donated following a disaster goes to relief efforts to help the survivors.

A paper by Ioannis Evangelidis and Bram Van den Bergh in the November, 2013 issue of Psychological Science explored the influences on people’s donations following disasters.
First, they analyzed the actual donations given following natural disasters that occurred from 2000-2011 using publicly accessible databases.  They looked both at the likelihood that money would be given following a particular disaster as well as the amount of money given.  They found that the number of fatalities following the disaster was associated with a higher likelihood that money would be given and that the amount of money given increased with the number of fatalities.  The number of people affected was not a significant predictor of either the likelihood that money would be given or the amount given.  The researchers then obtained a similar pattern in laboratory studies that described disasters using both the number of fatalities and number of affected survivors.

The authors suggest that this pattern of giving is a problem, because money is urgently needed to help survivors.  An earthquake that kills only 100 people, but leaves a million people homeless and without food and water leaves a lot of people who need help, even though the earthquake did not kill many people.  So, the researchers explored two ways to get people to pay more attention to the number of survivors rather than to the number of individuals killed in the disaster.

In one study, they asked half of the participants to compare two disasters directly: one that killed 4,500 people and left 7,500 affected survivors and a second that killed 7,500 and left 4,500 affected survivors.  They had to rank them according to which should get more aid.  Afterward, they read about a single disaster and were asked how much money they thought should be donated.  The number of individuals killed and the number of affected survivors was manipulated so that different people saw different combinations of the number killed and affected.

For those people in the control condition (who did not compare the two disasters), their pattern of donations was similar to that in previous studies.  They suggested higher donations for disasters with a large number of fatalities than for those with a low number of fatalities.  The number of affected survivors did not influence their judgments.  

Those who compared pairs of disasters first showed a different pattern.  They gave higher donations to disasters with a large number of affected survivors, while the number of fatalities did not influence suggested donations.  That is, when people compared two disasters first, it helped them to realize that the number of affected survivors is more important than the number of fatalities when determining the amount of aid needed.

A final study explored the possibility that people are unsure what it means for a survivor to be “affected” by a disaster.  This term is often used, because it covers the many problems people may face after a disaster.  So, some participants read about a disaster in which the survivors were “affected” while others read about a disaster in which the survivors were “homeless.”  Once again, the descriptions varied in the number of people who were killed or affected/homeless.  

In this study, when people were described as “affected” the typical pattern emerged.  The number of fatalities predicted the amount of aid people wanted to see given to the disaster.  When people were described as “homeless,” the number of fatalities had only a small influence on judgments, and the number of survivors had a much larger impact, particularly for disasters in which few people were killed.

Putting this all together, people’s judgments about donations to disasters are often influenced by the number of people killed in the disaster, even though the money is needed to help the survivors.  If people can be induced to think about the importance of the survivors and to recognize why they need aid, then that can shift the pattern of donation.  It will be interesting to see whether aid organizations begin to use these data to change the way they appeal to potential donors.