Friday, September 21, 2018

Can Liars Be Caught By Aviation Security?


If you travel frequently, then you have probably endured more than one security screening interview at an airport.  At passport control, for example, border agents ask a few questions, stare at your passport, check you on electronic databases, and then send you on your way.
The purpose of these interviews, of course, is to catch people who are being deceptive.  This is a remarkably difficult job.  Thousands of people are streaming through airports every day, and only a very small fraction of them are actually being deceptive in any significant way. 
Can those few liars be caught effectively?
This question was explored in a field study by Thomas Ormerod and Coral Dando published in the February, 2015 issue of the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General. 
They trained two samples of security agents on different methods of screening for deception. 
One method focused on finding suspicious signs that are supposed to distinguish lairs from truth-tellers.  This technique, which is typical of what is taught to security screeners, involves a scripted set of questions.  As passengers answer these questions, agents look for signs of deception like nervousness or a passenger dressed inappropriately for the trip they are going on.
The other method focused on the security interview itself.  This technique uses a lot of open-ended questions designed to get the passengers to talk about themselves.  The agent asks questions of general knowledge that someone with that background should know.  For example, a passenger who claims to be a student at the University of Texas should know where the Student Union is or how to get to the airport from campus.  The technique is designed to give the passenger very little control over the direction of the interview.  Deceptive individuals like to control the conversation, so that they can focus on the details that they want to discuss.
After this training, about 200 deceptive passengers were sent through security over an 8-month period.  Notice, this means that most passengers that any agent saw were genuine passengers.  The deceptive passengers were recruited to participate in the study.  They were given payment to be in the study and a significant amount of additional money if they passed through security without being called aside for further screening.  So, the deceptive passengers had some incentive to get through security.  The ability to detect whether this group was deceptive was compared to the screeners’ likelihood of sending genuine passengers for extra screening whose demographic characteristics matched those of the experimental sample. 
A few weeks before participating in the study, the deceptive passengers were given a cover story to learn that was tailored to their age and appearance.  The example given in the paper was a male police officer who was told to imagine that he was working as an engineer near his hometown and was traveling to Chicago to take part in a fencing competition.  The deceptive passengers were told to do research to add information to their backstory.  A subset of the deceptive passengers were also given several opportunities to be deceptive at different times, to see if they could improve in their ability to fool the screeners.
The results were striking.  Screeners trained with the interview technique caught about 70% of the deceptive passengers, while those trained with the traditional method of looking for cues detected about 5% of the passengers.
You might thing this reflected that the screeners trained with the interview technique just sent more people for additional questioning than those trained in the traditional way.  That was not the case.  The agents who learned the interview technique were no more likely to send other passengers for additional screening than those who were trained in the traditional way. 
You might also think that the interview technique takes longer.  It does not.  Agents trained with each technique spent about 3 minutes with each passenger.  The big difference was that those trained with the interview technique asked more open-ended questions and gave the passengers more time to speak than those trained in the traditional way.
Finally, those passengers who were given several opportunities to get through screening were caught at about the same rate for each try.  This finding suggests that it was not straightforward for passengers to learn to beat the system. 
The reason why the system is hard to beat is straightforward.  If you claim to be someone very different from who you are, there is a wealth of life experience that you simply don’t have.  All of the specific details of life from where you shop to how you drive home to what buildings you pass on your way home are second-nature when you are telling the truth and are absent when you are involved in a large-scale deception.  These security interviews allow agents to capitalize on the absence of this knowledge when interviewing passengers.
Finally, this research is a great demonstration of the way that psychological research can be used to solve a practical problem.  First, the interview technique itself is drawn from extensive research on deception.  Second, the test itself is quite well-constructed, and the researchers do a good job of ruling out a number of alternative explanations for the results.

33 comments:

  1. Very interesting. I wonder though at the training of the passengers. Would they be more successful if they were trained to be persuasive such as successful salespeople or lawyers, or maybe trained to take on a role such as an experienced actor. I wonder if a study could be made of what training would make one successful as a better "liar". I think using successful politicians to be the deceptive passengers might change the results.

    ReplyDelete
  2. We can learn a lot about Why Deep Learning Works by studying the properties of the layer weight matrices of pre-trained neural networks. And, hopefully, by doing this, we can get some insight into what a well trained DNN looks like–even without peaking at the training data.
    MACHINE LEARNING training in chennai

    ReplyDelete
  3. As you have now understood the usage of ‘Record and Playback’ tool, the following are the different posts using which you can explore the functioning of ‘Selenium IDE’
    selenium Training in chennai

    ReplyDelete
  4. As you have now understood the usage of ‘Record and Playback’ tool, the following are the different posts using which you can explore the functioning of ‘Selenium IDE’
    selenium Training in chennai

    ReplyDelete
  5. All Online Assignment help is a web portal where students get help in making assignments for all the subjects, with the help of our experts. You will get 100% plagiarism free assignment. Expert’s consultation is also available for students. If they have any query they can contact with our experts anytime.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Once you have done this a few times you should have a big targeted list of people who like and are interested in what you are trying to promote. Send them bulletins with updates on how your business offer is going and some other information they mind find useful 3312 exam questions answers.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Get report writing help services by the very qualified and experienced assignment experts of Ireland Assignment Help. Our professional tutors are fluent in writing assignment as they are the degree holder from top colleges and universities around the world.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree with you. Students need a lot of time to get the right grasp over things. But the problem is homework never stops, that's where teachers go wrong, loading them with the work. I think websites like Go Assignment Help, help in such cases with their help my assignment Services.

    ReplyDelete
  9. It was a very good post indeed. I thoroughly enjoyed reading it in my lunch time. Will surely come and visit this blog more often. Thanks for sharing. bodyguard company Houston Texas

    ReplyDelete
  10. This is the right blog for anyone who wishes to find out about this topic.
    You realize a whole lot its almost tough to
    argue with you (not that I personally will need to…HaHa).
    You definitely put a brand new spin on a subject that
    has been written about for decades. Wonderful stuff,
    just excellent!
    I have shared this link with other keep posting such information to provide cdr report, Rpl Report, KA02 Report at very affordable prices. So Visit Here :
    ict system test engineer 263213
    ict trainer australia

    ReplyDelete

  11. This is really fascinating, You’re an overly skilled blogger.
    I’ve joined your feed and sit up for in quest of more of your great post.
    If You need CDR Report, Rpl Report, KA02 Report, Summary Statement, CPD then We are here for you to minimize your difficulty in making reports. Visit:
    engineering cdr
    cdr writing services in chennai

    ReplyDelete
  12. This is the best thing that I must say that it should be done. However, the security protocols must be followed as per directions by dissertation writing services.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Just have a visit to our site, have a chat with the support team and give us a chance to serve you in the best possible way with Assignment Help.
    Why we are great? 2800+ experts covering every subject, 24/7 online support, short time assignment completed, refund and rework policy, low prices, 100% plagiarism free and assignment help online. This year be tension free with academic assignments with assignment help Canada.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Best post, Java has never been really my forte. It gives me bad dream whenever i sit to write my Java programming assignment. So this is the reason that I chose Java Assignment Help experts who write my programming assignments according my language. They carry out enormous performance throughout the assignments which help me to get earned marks every year.
    Java Assignment Help
    Java Programming Help
    Java Programmer Help

    ReplyDelete
  15. Does your business work hamper a lot with HP printer? Many times, an individual is keen to take the multiple hard copies of your electronic stream based work. No matter what the presence of your inventory data and details is, one should have to contact HP printer technical support number as countless flaws are regularly appearing in it. This number has been picked by various technocrats to diagnose the thing what is going in your account. It is always expected to reach at our third party professional team regardless the category of problem. Our efficient team has the full knowledge how to get rectify from various problems. Our team is highly focused about to rectify all problems shortly. You can call to our technical team as you are highly conscious about to get rectification of problem. Sooner and later, all hp printer users are bound to get the solution of every problem. In order to know more information, you can browse our web portal. https://www.hpprintersupportpro.com/hp-printer-tech-support


    Hp tech support
    Hp technical support
    hp tech support number
    hp technical support number
    hp tech support phone number
    hp technical support phone number
    hp printer tech support
    hp printer technical support
    hp printer tech support number
    hp printer technical support number
    hp printer tech support phone number
    hp printer technical support phone numbert
    Hp Printer Support Phone Number

    ReplyDelete
  16. Great! Knowledge expressed by you thanks for it. assignment help

    ReplyDelete
  17. Your one phone can save your newly installed Canon printer from several issues. Just give a ring to Canon Printer Customer Service Number and join hands with me. Here, I am available all day and night even on holidays to assist the needy ones like you. Thus, dial this number and resolve your entire printer related issues from the root. canon customer service
    canon customer service number
    canon customer service phone number
    canon printer customer service
    canon printer customer service number
    canon printer customer service phone number


    ReplyDelete
  18. It is really nice piece of information, but I don't think making video game is that much simple, but I found some hopes through it. Thanks for sharing. Every one should stay updated in technology.

    ReplyDelete
  19. In a competitive world, Assignment Writing Help me a lot with its effective and unique idea to present my work in an platable manner to score good marks. It provides a methodology to attract good marks in assignment. Thanks for your kind support to me.
    Assignment Help
    Assignment Help Online
    Online Assignment Help
    Assignment Help Online Services
    Assignment Helper
    Assignment Assistance
    Assignment Help Experts
    Online Assignment Help Services

    ReplyDelete
  20. HP printer assistant is one of famous utility software offered by HP for their users to manage HP device. If you want automatic updates, troubleshooting, error updates then use HP Printer Assistant. For more help you can contact a certified expert to fix HP printer related issues.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Nice article and thanks for sharing this to us. You explained in a nice way. Here will help you with all any technical issue difficulties in using Microsoft Office products and will resolve all your any doubts regarding the setup, password reset and installation process etc. calling the tech support team will save your time and money. Office 365 Support

    ReplyDelete
  22. Does any of your Hp products like your printer, not working properly? Not to worry. Hp tech support is there to provide all the solution for your problems. You just have to call on the Hp technical support phone number and the Hp professionals will be there for your help. Hp has a group of professionals which is there to provide any sort of help in just one call. Our professionals are available 24*7 to satisfy the customers by their help by sorting all kinds of technical problems. So if you are facing any technical problem, you can directly contact us and then we provide the professional at no time. For more information you can go through our website. https://www.hpprintersupportpro.com/hp-printer-tech-support

    Hp tech support
    Hp technical support
    hp tech support number
    hp technical support number
    hp tech support phone number
    hp technical support phone number
    hp printer tech support
    hp printer technical support
    hp printer tech support number
    hp printer technical support number
    hp printer tech support phone number
    hp printer technical support phone numbert
    Hp Printer Support Phone Number

    ReplyDelete

  23. You’re superb and I think you are the master of your topic. I like the way of your writing and please keep up posting. Visit on my Outlook support web page, if you need any type of Microsoft Outlook Support.

    Microsoft Outlook Support

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thank you for sharing such a decent post. I am working as a technical executive support for Microsoft Office products. I am offering support for Microsoft Office and If you need help then contact Office 365 Support . Call us on toll-free number +1-888-777-2832

    ReplyDelete
  25. Our metal detectors meet the requirements of the Federal Aviation Administration and the National Institute of Law Enforcement. www.securinadetection.com

    ReplyDelete
  26. Allassignmenthelp reviews
    has helped many students to choose the right website. It has also helped the students to score good grades in their academics. Our writing services review will help you to find the best writing websites for your success.

    ReplyDelete
  27. It is not easy to maintain a device to keep it error free. You need some maintaining or repair services to keep working with the HP device. You should visit hp.com/support to get in touch with certified experts to avail quick service. Certified experts are available round the clock to help customers regarding HP device.

    ReplyDelete