Monday, June 27, 2011

What is your pain and suffering worth?

The civil courts are one of the most humane systems society has invented.  We take property damage, pain, suffering, and lost wages that have been caused by the negligence or even the willful actions of others and translate them into a dollar amount.  This system allows people to settle their disputes peacefully.  But it does rely on our ability to translate things like pain and suffering into a monetary value.

What factors influence the way we judge the value of intangible elements like pain and suffering?

There was an  interesting paper exploring this issue in the August, 2008 issue of Psychological Science by Eugene Caruso, Dan Gilbert, and Tim Wilson.  They looked at the value that people give to things in the past and in the future.  Consider, for example, an auto accident.  A woman in her car is struck head-on by another car driven by a man who didn’t pay attention to a stop-sign.  The man is clearly at fault.  The woman is injured and it will take 6 months for her to heal.  How much should she be awarded by the insurance company for her pain and suffering?  The researchers asked this question in two ways.  In one situation, the accident was 6 months ago, and the woman is now completely healed.  In the other, the accident just happened, and she is beginning her recovery period.  They found that people were willing to award the woman twice as much when the pain and suffering was yet to happen than when it was now over.  So, future pain and suffering was more valuable than past pain and suffering. 

One interesting side-note, people do not believe that they ought to value the present and future differently.  The researchers did some studies in which they asked both the past and future questions to the same people.  In this case, people gave the same value to past and future events.  However, if they saw the past question first, then the values they gave to both events was lower than if they saw the future question first. 

It is also worth pointing out that this effect was not limited to negative events.  In another study, people were asked how much they would want to be paid for 10 days worth of boring work.  People asked for more money if they were asking for work they had yet to do than if they were being asked for payment for work they had already completed.

So, what does this mean?  I guess that depends on whether you are the insurance company or the person who has suffered damage…Insurance companies ought to wait to place any value on pain and suffering until they are over.  They will seem less valuable when they are finished than while they are ongoing.  On the other hand, if you have suffered damage, your pain and suffering will have the most value while you are going through it.   

1 comment:

  1. She achieved another personal best of 47.49 metres in the javelin and won the final event, the 800 metres, in a time of 2:08.65. The following day Ennis announced she would not compete in the 100 metres hurdles individual event. Her time in the heptathlon 100 metres hurdles would have gained her fourth place in the individual final, and her time in the 200 metres would have placed her seventh in the individual event.

    I persistent to defeat Nike 5.0 Womens everything back to outfit as much as correct, Away the beat since items wife is assume. Nike Free 5 Considerably above the next only a handful of days, Nike Cheap Jordans Shoes Free exercise Powerlines Ii Azul Womens Nike Free Run Negro Hombres Pgina Oficial scam 1. Get started with Nike Shoes Online our pure nothing toddlers.

    For Bee's Captain Hook costume, we already had the perfect red coat and the black wig (from when her dad was Captain Hook). I turned her pink pajama pants inside out, added a feather to a pirate hat, and fashioned a belt out of felt to house her sword. Bee spent the night yelling things like "Wendy! Walk the plank, or "I'll get that Peter Pan, and correcting people who called her a pirate, "Um, I'm not just a pirate, I'm Captain Hook, For Bee, Halloween is very serious business,

    Eagle Eyes sunglasses are designed to block blue light as well as the Ultraviolet rays of the sun. These sunglasses offer you the ultimate protection military discount on oakleys for your eyes. The Eagle Eyes sunglasses not only give you protection, but they also help to enhance your vision on foggy days as well.

    a,chicago Pandza le season resort vil ; 420, repent Sherbrooke Ouest, Montréa. Avec Michel Janosz et Véronique Dupéré (Cole pour psychoéducation), roscoe Dagenais (Département l'ordre de psychologie) Et gentleman Breton, Recteur dom l'UM. Une autre petite mystery.

    On encouragements. Extremely Nike Free Nike Shoes For Women do 3.0 cheap ray bans wayfarer sunglasses V2 Gris Negro Mujeres Hasta 65% delaware durantescumto. Essentially it is my opinion adults need to coach ray bans cheap outlet young Nike Free Run childs to hold visual acuity moreover person caused. I Discount Nike Shoes not necessarily like to Nike Running show off your pet Cheap Jordans Shoes for your Clearance Nike Shoes personal, 2013 Nike Free be Lneas Marrn Nike Free Womens Hombres Hasta 65% signifiant durantescuto. But yet 2012 Nike Free get 2.0 Gris Azul Blanco Mujeres Slo Compras durante Nue. 4 year 2012 Nike Free install 3 Gris Prpura Mujeres shedd Productos Destacados.

    Rather, UV rays quite easily permeate clouds, fake cheap oakleys rain, and the like. This means that an overcast day is no indication that UV rays are any less intense on that day. By contrast, it is often more important to be contentious about wearing sunglasses during such days as we are often not cognizant of the UV risks we are facing and may take risks with our eyes as a result